Man Utd News: Ruben Amorim Dropped, Paul Scholes Calls for Departure of Duo

Ruben Amorim Faces Challenges at Manchester United

Ruben Amorim is facing a tough start to his tenure as manager of Manchester United, with the team continuing to struggle despite a significant investment in new players during the summer transfer window. The club spent £230 million on additions such as Bryan Mbeumo, Matheus Cunha, Benjamin Sesko, and Senne Lammens. However, the results have not reflected this financial commitment, and the team has been plagued by poor performances.

One of the most notable moves during the summer was the loan of Marcus Rashford to Barcelona. The English forward, who had been a key player for United, left the club after being omitted from the squad in December 2024. He joined Aston Villa on loan earlier this season, where he found form again before making the move to Barcelona. Despite his departure, Rashford has received praise from Barcelona's manager, Hansi Flick, who described him as "incredible."

Amorim’s decision to let Rashford leave has sparked debate among fans and former players. Paul Scholes, a club legend, has also voiced his concerns about the manager's choices. Scholes criticized Amorim for retaining certain players, particularly Harry Maguire and Luke Shaw, who have not performed to the expected standard.

Criticism from Paul Scholes

Scholes highlighted the lack of physicality and quality in the current squad, pointing to Maguire and Shaw as examples. Maguire, 32, has only played 41 minutes in the Premier League this season, while Shaw, 30, has started every game but has been plagued by injuries. Scholes questioned whether Shaw is still fit enough to compete at the top level, noting that he has suffered numerous injuries since joining United in 2014.

He suggested that Shaw should have left the club in the summer, stating that he could have been the best left-back in the world if he had stayed fit. Instead, Shaw is now playing as a left-sided centre-half, which Scholes believes is not suitable for his abilities.

Maguire, meanwhile, is expected to play a limited role this season. Scholes expressed confusion over the club's decision to renew his one-year option, suggesting that they could have sold him for around £20-£30 million. He argued that the club missed an opportunity to generate revenue and improve their defensive options.

Amorim's Decisions and the Impact on the Squad

Amorim has made several changes to the squad, with five players departing either through permanent sales or loans. These include Andre Onana, Jadon Sancho, Antony, Rasmus Hojlund, and Alejandro Garnacho. However, the retention of Maguire and Shaw has drawn criticism from Scholes, who believes that the club needs to invest in better-quality players.

The challenges faced by Amorim are evident, with the team struggling to find consistency and form. The high expectations placed on the club mean that any missteps are scrutinized heavily. Fans are hoping that Amorim can turn things around, but the early signs are not encouraging.

As the season progresses, it will be interesting to see how Amorim manages to address these issues and rebuild the team. The pressure is on him to deliver results, and the support from the fans will be crucial in helping him achieve this goal.